Well, I’ll be damned. The mainstream media has finally discovered the Jewish Defense League. And only a decade or two too late. But why nitpick? Any old fool can condemn a terrorist group while it’s actively threatening and murdering people, but CNN didn’t get where it is today (the basement) by being rash and foolhardy (you know, like nearly going on air with the false announcement of a president’s death). Like a cobra with Down syndrome, CNN knows that the best time to strike is when the target is dead and motionless.
Because of my own history with the JDL (CliffsNotes version: The group tried to kill me), some of my friends understandably thought I’d cheer the clips they emailed me of CNN’s Ashleigh Banfield lecturing a Donald Trump supporter about how Jews are supposedly just as bad as Muslims when it comes to terrorism in the U.S.:
You know what? I’m going to tell ya something. There’s a guy named John Pistole, who just recently was running the TSA. Uh, real venerable guy. He, before that, was with the FBI. He was an executive assistant director for counterterror and counterintelligence and he sat before Congress in 2004 and he testified—and this is to your point about there are no Jews coming to hurt Americans—he testified about, from a period of 1980 to 1985, there were 18 terrorist attacks in the United States committed by Jews. Fifteen of them by members of the Jewish Defense League. The head of the Jewish Defense League was in jail awaiting trial on charges of trying to bomb a mosque in Culver City, trying to bomb Darrell Issa’s office, an Arab-American. What are you talking about?! There have been Jewish terrorist attacks! Should we therefore ask no Jews to please apply for a visa?… I’m telling you that there have been that many terrorist attacks committed by Jews and no one’s suggesting for a minute that all Jews should be wiped out of this country from visiting. It’s the same thing.
“Now that the JDL in the U.S. is no longer a threat, all of a sudden JDL terrorism matters, but only as a weapon to be wielded against critics of Islamic extremism.”
Banfield left out the anticlimactic coda. In December 2001, JDL forzitser Irv Rubin was arrested, along with his right-hand man Earl Krugel, for plotting to blow up Muslim targets in Southern California in retaliation for 9/11. He died in L.A. County lockup awaiting trial, and Krugel was murdered by a fellow inmate after pleading guilty to the charges. By 2005, Rubin and Krugel were dead, and the JDL existed in name only. JDL violence (in the U.S.) went the way of New Coke, the rotary phone, and Gallagher.
Frankly, I find CNN’s sudden “discovery” of JDL terrorism offensive and disingenuous. During the years that the group was terrorizing people like me, mainstream news organizations were dead silent. CNN especially. Prior to the December 2001 arrests, CNN.com didn’t feature one single story about JDL “terrorism.” In fact, when mentioned at all, the JDL was described only as an “activist group,” and the JDL website (the one that contained a death warrant calling for my violent demise) was routinely featured as a “related site” link in stories about the Middle East.
Now that the JDL in the U.S. is no longer a threat, all of a sudden JDL terrorism matters, but only as a weapon to be wielded against critics of Islamic extremism. This is cowardly and cynical. The fact is, as long as the JDL was attacking the “right” victims (real or perceived white racists and anti-Semites), the media turned a blind eye. Hell, worse than a blind eye. Rubin was a popular talk-show guest, his “terrorism” conveniently forgotten. Then–KABC talk show host Larry Elder even attended the man’s funeral, telling the L.A. Times, “I thought of him as a courageous champion for what he believed in. I thought of him as a hothead who often led with his mouth, but not someone who would kill people” (ironically, Elder would end up becoming my business partner during my years as a GOP organizer, never knowing that he was working with a man Rubin had indeed tried to kill).
Mainstream left and right ignored JDL violence because Rubin was going after the “white fringe”: Holocaust deniers, white nationalists, people with strong anti-Jewish views, and people like me, who were not deniers, racists, or anti-Semites, but who were tarred as such by the press. In July 1984, when the JDL firebombed the warehouse and library of the Holocaust revisionist/denial publishing house the Institute for Historical Review, the silence from the media moved Pulitzer Prize-winning author and historian John Toland to pen a letter condemning the blackout:
When I learned of the torching of the office-warehouse of the Institute for Historical Review I was shocked. And when I heard no condemnation of this act of terrorism on television and read no protests in the editorial pages of our leading newspapers or from the halls of academia, I was dismayed and incensed. Where are those defenders of democracy who over the years have so vigorously protested the burning of books by Hitler? Are they only summer soldiers of democracy, selective in their outrage? I call on all true believers in democracy to join me in public denunciation of the recent burning of books in Torrance, California
Alexander Cockburn expressed similar sentiments in his March 20, 1989, “Beat the Devil” column in The Nation. Slamming Western intellectuals for their hypocrisy in championing Salman Rushdie while turning a blind eye to the persecution of those who “blaspheme” Western orthodoxies, Cockburn wrote: “The outfit in the United States that does publish material belittling generally accepted accounts of the Nazi extermination of the Jews is called the Institute for Historical Review. I don’t recall much fuss when its offices in Torrance, California, were firebombed in July 1984. Perhaps this is what [Norman] Mailer meant by ‘sophistication’ in handling such heterodox opinion.”
When I was beaten up by a JDL member while giving a speech at UCLA in January 1992, crews from CBS News and the local Fox affiliate were covering the event. Although the attack was captured on camera, both networks chose not to mention the assault on air.
Even when the JDL did attack Muslims, as in the 1985 bombing in Southern California that killed Alex Odeh, regional director of the American-Arab Anti-Discrimination Committee, the media soft-pedaled the story. To the left, Muslims had yet to achieve “most favored victim” status. 9/11 would change that. Rubin’s alleged plot against Muslim targets finally fit a narrative that the mainstream media could be comfortable with. Following such a horrific and game-changing example of terrorism on the part of followers of the “religion of peace,” the media needed examples of non-Muslim terrorists for “balance.” In other words, the post-9/11 plot that led to the downfall of the JDL received media attention in December 2001 for the same reason JDL violence received attention from Ashleigh Banfield and CNN fourteen years later: It could be used as a handy device in the service of a grander scheme, I would go so far as to say an obsession, on the part of the mainstream media to downplay Muslim extremism by any means necessary.
The JDL as I knew it was made up of violent thugs and, indeed, domestic terrorists. They’ll get no sympathy from me. But whereas I find the JDL’s violence appalling and inexcusable, I find the smug posturing of Banfield, and the colleagues who applauded her “bravery,” vulgar and sickening. The national media was nowhere to be found when the IHR warehouse was torched, when George Ashley’s home was firebombed, when Cal State Long Beach professor Reinhard Buchner was assaulted, when the Holiday Inn and Red Lion hotel chains were threatened into canceling revisionist conferences, and when a $25,000 bounty was put on my head.
If Banfield had actually wanted to be “brave,” she could have questioned why her own bosses ignored so much JDL “terror” when it was actually happening. She might even have interviewed some of the survivors of the statistics she so arrogantly trumpeted. But no, she’d never be caught dead doing that. The majority of the JDL’s victims are as despised by the mainstream media as they were by Irv Rubin, and the media’s silence during the JDL’s campaign of terror against people like me damn near amounted to complicity.
After Banfield’s JDL rant, I reached out to my remaining contacts in the media to see if any of them would be interested in speaking with someone who had been on the receiving end of JDL terror (and I wasn’t just referring my myself; I offered to connect them to other victims of JDL violence). Again and again I was told that “people like me” would not be allowed on air or in print. And this, above all, is why I greet Banfield’s supposed “courage” with a massive yawn. Sure, the JDL wanted to silence “people like me,” but so does the mainstream media. The JDL used violence and intimidation, the media uses less illegal tactics. Same end, just different means. From where I sit, having been on the receiving end of JDL fists and media defamation and censorship, I’m loath to pick a favorite.
“Diverse” means formerly White… –Bob Whitaker
Bob Whitaker: A true American and former Reagan Administration appointee.
Political Power for European Americans!
European people should organize and advance their own interests just like every other group. Join our fight for Heritage and Identity!
The American Freedom Party needs your help! Send $10, $20, $50, $100, or any contribution you can via PayPal “Send Money” to firstname.lastname@example.org or click here:
The American Freedom Party (AFP) supports the right to keep and bear arms. Emancipate yourself from the dinosaur Democrat and Republican parties. Join a National Party that puts America first, The American Freedom Party!
Support American Freedom Party growth and our heritage of Western civilization! The American Freedom Party is the only party that addresses issues concerning European-American communities and all Americans.
Nationalism! Not Globalism! — America First! Not America Last!
Freedom from Republicans. Freedom from Democrats. American Freedom Party! Political Power for European-Americans!
European-Americans should push back! European-Americans should abandon the Republicans and Democrats. Change your party allegiance to the American Freedom Party. A Nationalist party that shares the customs and heritage of the European American people. We need a Nationalist Party interested in defending our borders, preserving our language and promoting our culture. The American Freedom Party is not beholden to foreign governments, special interest groups, nor Wall Street. The American Freedom Party is for America First!